Try this
- Repeat the preference accurately and identify the practical adjustment you will make.
- Avoid praising honesty and then immediately trying to negotiate the answer away. Ask only about genuinely open alternatives.
A worked example
“Thanks for telling me you don’t enjoy surprise outings. I’ll ask before booking anything next time.”
An invented example to adapt, not a real exchange or a script you have to follow.
Before you leave it here
If you feel disappointed, you can say so without making the person responsible for retracting their preference.